According to Consumer Reports, 2022 buyer's guide issue, the top three tires that meet your criterial (ultra-high performance all-season tires with Y speed rating (186 MPH)) are:
1. Goodyear Exhilarate
2. Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 4
3. General G-MAX AS-05
Notes: The Goodyear and General tires have better than average noise suppression. (Michelin is average in this category.)
General tires are rated average in wet braking, whereas the other two choices are rated as better than average.
The Michelin and General are rated much better than average in the dry braking category, whereas the Goodyear is rated as average.
Tread life:
Goodyear: 45,000 miles
Michelin: 55,000 miles
General: 65,000 miles
As expected, General tires tend to be over 20% less expensive. The Goodyears and Michelins tend to be somewhat close in price, with the Goodyears being a bit less expensive., according to Tirerack.