I subscribe to CR (or at least a family member gives me a gift subscription at Christmas every single year). The CR reliability surveys and charts are very useful and probably the best available in the industry. I monitor and have verified this data against cars I actually own (past/present).
I don't give much weight to road tests, they are not very good. Yes, they do good appliance reviews including fridges, BBQs, toasters.
I have long history of no loyalty to any one auto maker, having owned brands including Lexus, Toyota, Mercedes, Porsche, Honda, Acura, Jag, Ford, Hummer, Mercury, Mazda and Jeep.
When it comes to comparisons, I reach my own conclusions based on multiple road tests/reviews and my own test drives.