I am insured with Plymouth Rock. When my car went into the shop for repair of the damage from the drunk driver, the Plymouth Rock van went to the body shop, assessed the damage, discussed it with the shop, agreed on a total price and generated a signed check right on the spot.
That is the only claim I have had with them so I can only base experience with them on that one instance.
2002 bank financed ES, excellent history/rating, full coverage, highest security allowance, moderately low theft area: $1100/year.
steviej