Looking over some of these posts, it seems I am not the only one with a slowly leaking spare that sets the warning light. The dealer has never found a leak, tho it has been alarming since new. When the light first came on, I kept checking the tires, not knowing that the spare had a sensor too.
Now that I have rotated, the tire was down by 5# after the light was on for a few weeks. Those sensors are so sensitive. the dealer gave me a printout on their sensitivity, and I think it said they alarm with a 1.5# drop. I bought a digital tire gauge because my old one wasn't accurate enough to find the culprit.
Has anyone else had this problem? I don't know why the spare would be an issue.
Plus <my rant>, does anyone else hate the spare? I'd rather have a mini. It doesn't mess up the rotation pattern, and isn't a pain to get to every 4 months. Plus, you have one less alloy wheel to pay for (not that that would reduce the cost of the car any...) To me, if a tire goes bad, you put the mini on and drive to the shop to get it fixed or replaced. (unfortunately, the reality is all the crappy cars you see going around a bend at 75 on the highway. The mini will likely be bald, and the car will have kids in it... That doesn't mean a real spare would be in any better shape, but would likely have a much better load bearing capacity!)
Added bonus... The manual states that the 5 tire rotation is front to back, but all tire sites say to cross-rotate, like they did at the dealership I once worked at. In the 70's radials were directionally rotated, but either better manufacturing or better research has changed this to cross-rotation.
(LF to LR, LR-RF, RF-Sp, Sp-RR, RR-LF)
Once you replace your tires, save the best for the spare and do the standard 4 tire cross (LF-LR, LR-RF, RF-RR, RR-LF)