AppleJack,
Take your rebuilt starter to your local pepboys, advanced auto, trak auto etc. and have them bench test the starter. Most offer this service for free.
Do not crank it while someone is holding the starter, very bad idea. The starter will put out so much torque it will probably fly all over the place.
I would also advise against trying to crank it with the top-end uninstalled. More risk then it's worth.
Regards
Nick T