Uhhh... Do you guys know why a particular octane rating is even necessary? (let's stick to the Octane Rating stated on the pump, not talk in Research Octane Numbers)
- octane effectively reveals resistance to detonation (burning of the fuel before the spark plugs ignite it)
- the engine's compression ratio (and environmental conditions) determine a detonation point, which means listen to your owner's manual as to which octane to use, as that's what it was designed for.
- exception: in RARE cases, the owner's manual is out of date (happened to Subaru) and a different octane can be found to work as well or better
- for a given engine with a specific compression ratio, as long as you are not detonating, you will get the same power no matter what octane you use
- exception: modern car computers and sensing devices (like knock sensors) are able to detect knocking (detonation) before the driver can even feel it and will adjust the timing (usually !Removed!) to avoid this problem. This protects the engine, at the cost of performance efficiency... which means the driver will feel like his car is "sluggish".
- sometimes the environmental conditions are such that you can use a lower octane gas without problems, but this is not a realable way to go as environmental conditions fluctuate too much.
Bottom line, you best bet (usually) is to stick to the octane rating your owner's manual says to; no more, no less.