SK, Thanks for the response. There was no bushing in the strut that I took out nor the new strut that I bought. From what I took out, there was only a strut, spring, 2 rubber isolator (top and bottom), boot and the mount. I reused the isolators and spring. I replaced everything else.
I re-looked at the center nut again and it is on pretty tight. It moves just a slight bit up and down cause it's mounted on a rubber bushing inside the mount. I believe this is how it's supposed to work. While it's moving, it's also making some clicking noise, but only on some bumps.
I realized that when I took the seats out, there is a piece of sound insulation (a foam type material) the size of a brick that fits directly over the center nut and the mount. I put them back on and they seem to completely eliminate the noise. I'll put the seat back and see if insulates the rest of the vibration and tire noise.
I think that will do the trick. I'll let you know. Thanks for the response though.