Thanks for the comments (and I LOVE your picture!!!)
Yeah, it's a moot point now - we have to rent the minivan for this trip considering the amount to move. But we've had this discussion for trips to both kids schools which are 11 - 13 hours away each. Doesn't happen often though!
I'm hoping to get a reassurance that we're not paying 'too much'. Through costco a couple weeks ago when we first thought about this, we could have gotten a minivan for $350 for the 4 days we need it, thought that was high and skipped making a non-binding reservation. Now we know we need it and it's $550 : (
Yeah, we own it, have an 8? year extended warranty on it, expect to keep it a long time (200K?! how long does it take to get that many miles for you and what are you spending each year near the end?).
Even if you don't care about how many miles, at some low price, most people would say - yeah, I'll rent. Let's see. We're going to pay $550 for the rental and saves us from putting 1,500 miles on the car, so we're spending 36c a mile. 'seems' high. again, a moot point since we need the minivan. but on another trip when we could fit things in the SUV, I'd like to know what number would be the breakpoint.
And this could be a whole separate thing. I drive a dinged up honda civic 2010. It's my wife that wanted the bigger / nicer Lexus... after 200K, does it still look good? Are you buying for the appearance / features (leather, sunroof, etc.) or the quality to get to 200K? Think the Toyotas would go as far (if you are getting it for the quality, Toyota is cheaper right?)