It looks like the second photo (open). As you say, I can make it move to 'closed' by pressing on it, but the minute I let up, it goes right back to the open position, and of course the trunk won't close with it in that position. I saw a thread over on club lexus where someone had a similar problem and turned out it was a broken wire in the trunk wiring harness. If it's not that, then I need a new trunk latch. As I said, I did try to remove the trunk liner about a week ago, and though I did not use much force (at all), it's possible that even gentle pressure in a certain area coudl have broken a wire. I was trying to get in there to replace a burnt out license plate bulb. Should have left it alone!