For those considering new tires, I rely on the Tirerack "survey" results to help make my choice. I have found their survey results to be pretty good as far as giving you basic info.on the good or bad as far as comparing different tires. I have ordered tires from Tirerack 2 X, and they ship the next business day (UPS), and you get your tires within a few days time. Sometimes Discount Tire/America's Tire will match their price.
I just purchased a 2010 Lexus 450h last week and looked up the tires on Tirerack (Bridgestone Dueler H/L 400's). They were rated as very poor in general (rank 56 out of 58 for highway all-season),and especially for rain/winter conditions. I decided to order new tires from Tirerack and will be replacing these this week (< 200 miles on the OEM tires). I opted for the Michelin Latitude Tour HP as they were rated pretty good and they had the size (235/55R19) for my SUV. If the Bridgestone Dueler Alenza's or the standard Michelin Latitude's had come in that size, I would have ordered those since they are rankled # 2 and # 1 respectively in their class of tire.