Jaswood, 'Thomas',
I don't recall if my CEL came on then, but here's another related issue that may help some looking here.
Just a few weeks after my post, my wife calls to tell the car is acting up, no power, thankfully only a block or two from home, but barely made it up our fairly steep side road. I get home from work and check it out. Acted just like before so I do the 'coil test' i mentioned before and, sure enough, with the coil removed from the driver's side coil it still runs the same, when removed from the top coil it won't start. I replaced the coil and....no change! Bummer. So I start thinking about it more and I remembered a key issue. When I had the coil wire off the 'bad' coil it was arcing all over, I was in a hurry and guess I thought that maybe the top of the coil was cracked or something. So I finally used my brain and started to check downstream, i.e. distributor and rotor. Well, when I started to remove the distributor cap, a bunch of little pieces and powder were falling out. I got a rag and tried to prevent as much as possible from falling down into the timing area. Anyway, the rotor had basically disintegrated. Sooo, same symptom of running on 4 cylinders, but different cause. Here's the kicker...no CEL. Hmmm. I think it works because is comes on at start up and it blinked rapidly when I checked for codes. Oh well, on to the next repair.
Peace